
AUTHOR Marcus Sedgwick
PUBLICATION April 22nd 2014 by Square Fish
READ June 17 to 18, 2013
SOURCE Purchased


Have you ever had the feeling that you've lived another life? Been somewhere that has felt totally familiar, even though you've never been there before, or felt that you know someone well, even though you are meeting them for the first time? It happens. In 2073 on the remote and secretive island of Blessed, where rumour has it that no one ages and no children are born, a visiting journalist, Eric Seven, and a young local woman known as Merle are ritually slain. Their deaths echo a moment ten centuries before, when, in the dark of the moon, a king was slain, tragically torn from his queen. Their souls search to be reunited, and as mother and son, artist and child, forbidden lovers, victims of a vampire they come close to finding what they've lost. In a novel comprising seven parts, each influenced by a moon - the flower moon, the harvest moon, the hunter's moon, the blood moon - this is the story of Eric and Merle whose souls have been searching for each other since their untimely parting.

I had a tough time easing into this one. The writing is what I have come to expect of a gothic novel in that it feels rather old and formal. However, once I was able to get into the flow of the prose I did get sucked into the story. We are treated to 7 stories that are in revers chronological order. So we start off in 2073 and work our way all the way back to before the 10th century. I’m not sure how I felt about this, I mean I liked it but it seemed to me that things were overlapping in a way that could only happen if time were moving forward. For example, the second story tells a tale of an archaeological dig in 2011 that takes place on Blessed Island in which they find a coffin (cairn) that contains two bodies. Jump one story after that and it is 1944 and we get the story of a fallen airman who finds himself stranded on the island with a broken ankle. He reads in the paper about an archaeological dig on an island that he just knows he has been to before. See, it makes sense if time is moving forward, but how did someone in the past make that connection. Unless he lived the 7 lives in reverse, but that just doesn’t make sense because the 7th life was in 2073. See! I am confused folks, maybe something went over my head here, and I am going to look like an idiot when someone explains it to me but this is how I feel right now.
I did enjoy the epicness of the love story here. I loved how we got the end of their story in the beginning and worked our way back, so I guess you can say I liked the general idea of it though the execution left me scratching my head a bit. Reading all the stories and connecting little strings was fun. Every time a new one would start I was so excited to find out who Eric and Merle were in that life. I also did come to really enjoy the darkness of the writing. In my head it read very ominously and I did feel a little creeped out during the last few stories.
Midwinterblood is beautifully written, incredibly dark novel that will make you long for a love like the one you are reading. I do wish that I didn’t end up being so confused for most of it because I do think that it took away from my immediate enjoyment of the novel but looking back it’s definitely a solid story worth reading.
Wow, I must admit my eyes began to cross a little as I read through that synopsis. Talk about an overwhelming concept to summarize in a few short sentences!
ReplyDeleteThat said, it does sound interesting. I adore Gothic novels and love the idea of a love story that transcends time, but like you, I'm not too keen on the way in which this story seems to be told. It sounds like it makes an already confusing concept unnecessarily difficult to follow and I'm certainly hesitant to pick up this particular book because of the manner in which it seems to be told. Unfortunately, I'm not sure this is the right book for me.
Wonderful review, Jenni! :)
I love the writing style in gothic novels. I have to say the whole 7 stories told in reverse is quite intriguing. I'm not sure if I'd actually like it or not. Love how you described the love story. I kind of want to read it just for that, as shallow as that might sound.
ReplyDeleteStill, I'm not sure this book is for me.
Lovely review, Jenni!
I usually love epic love stories that transcend time (provided they're written well, not like Fallen- which unfortunately, I did not like). I find working backwards in time really intriguing, however I do understand how it would be so confusing. But I guess I'd still like to try a book written like that! I'm glad you enjoyed this overall, Jenni<3 Lovely review! :))
ReplyDeleteWow. This sounds really complex, my head hurts just thinking about the reverse order of events. And if we're moving back in time, how did that pilot know about the dig? The love story aspect sound fantastic though, I'm always on board for a good romance, but I think I'm going to pass on this one just because I so hate being confused while reading. Beautiful review though Jenni!
ReplyDeleteI liked the writing too. I thought it was very beautiful and atmospheric.I too wasn't sure how I felt about the story. I did like it, but didn't love it like so many other people have! Great review!!
ReplyDeleteThis seems like a very cool concept, but I think I would have a verrry hard time getting into it. I'm glad the writing was so enjoyable for you. Thanks for sharing, Jenni!
ReplyDeleteThe writing in this one sounds so good! I'll have to give it a go!
ReplyDeleteI don't know why, but the cover doesn't hint romance for me (although if I look at the cover more closely, I see a heart. hmhh..). I don't see this one being for me, I have enjoyed very few gothic novels and I've yet to read my sequel copy of Michelle Zink's gothic series about two sisters. I think this'll be enough gothic for me for this year lol. However, this one seems so very complex *__* I probably would have difficulty getting into this one as well. At least you enjoyed the love story more. I know a lot of the times romance ruins a book for you, so I'm glad this wasn't the case here:-)
ReplyDeleteIt does sounds like a love story that I would like maybe a little confusing on the other fronts. And this is completely new to me. :) Great review.
ReplyDeleteI've never heard of a book treating time the way that it seems this one does. And it seems very confusing. In combination with formal writing made for Gothic novels, I could see why the execution wasn't quite what you expected. That's a shame, too, though because it sounds so perfect otherwise: dark writing and epic love interspersed with history. (And hey! They changed the cover. That's good. I really didn't like the old one.)
ReplyDeleteI agree that this one was definitely a bit confusing, but in the end, it really grew on me and I ended up liking it quite a bit. It's just so different! I have no clue why it was classified as YA though.
ReplyDeleteI like dark novels but the love story kinda makes me want to run away a bit. But I'm glad you found it enjoyable, despite the ending being a little confusing. I get really bummed with that happens :|
ReplyDeleteBrilliant review, Jenni! <33
This doesn't sound like a horror. It seems like YA has trouble properly labeling things horror. But this story does sound dark and I love an epic romance -- particularly when it leaves me wanting what those characters have. But the confusion factor does sound like it'd hinder someone's enjoyment. I'll be putting this on my TBR list, though I'm not positive I'll get it.
ReplyDeleteDarn! I am so sorry that you didn't enjoy this one more!
ReplyDelete