AUTHOR Sarah Skilton
PUBLICATION March 5th 2013 by Amulet/Abrams
READ May 11 to 12, 2013
SOURCE Purchased

When Imogen, a sixteen-year-old black belt in Tae Kwon Do, freezes during a holdup at a local diner, the gunman is shot and killed by the police, and she blames herself for his death. Before the shooting, she believed that her black belt made her stronger than everyone else -- more responsible, more capable. But now her sense of self has been challenged and she must rebuild her life, a process that includes redefining her relationship with her family and navigating first love with the boy who was at the diner with her during the shootout. With action, romance, and a complex heroine, Bruised introduces a vibrant new voice to the young adult world -- full of dark humor and hard truths.
Imogen is a black belt in Tae Kwon Do, her ranking and the fact that she didn’t do anything to take the gunman down during the heist is wreaking havoc inside her. Immediately after the event I really felt for her and I was sad that she was struggling so much with her self confidence. I could understand why she was beating herself up over it after having gotten so far and mastered her colors in TKD. But somewhere along the way her inner turmoil just lost me and I started to feel as if it was a bit grating. This is entirely personal and I know that there are tons of people who disagree with me but I started to kind of glaze over to her emotions. I longed for more to happen outside of her strife and inner dialogue that was essentially beating herself up.
She does make a great connection with Ricky (another survivor of the heist) he was a sweet guy but failed to become more than that. I think there were quite a few missed connections in the story and looking back there was so much potential. Imogen is in a fight with her very best friend and I wanted to get to see them work it out, she is having a hard time accepting her brother’s sleazy ways and I wanted to see them work it out, but there was so much turmoil which led up to some very short resolutions in the end. I think had I gone on more of the ups & downs in these relationships I would have connected to them more, but it was pretty much always down and I never got to experience the peaks. One relationship that I could connect to was between Imogen and her father. As someone who has a father who struggles with overeating greatly affecting his health I could feel the frustrations that she felt when looking at him. I latched onto those moments and was happy that we got to go through more with those two than with the relationships I mentioned previously.
An interesting look at PTSD and how it can affect a teenagers life, BRUISED was a read that kept me entertained for a day and a half but it’s not one that I will be thinking about for a long time to come. I think this is a solid read but I wish I had gotten more out of it. But hey, look at all the glowing reviews on Goodreads, maybe you will get something more out of it than me.


In order to get a driving license I had to go to a one day first-aid training, but I wouldn't say I was an expert on how to give first-aid if there was a car accident somewhere and I happen to see it. The thing is that I'd probably freeze. And we were told that in a situation where human brain tends to panic, only 1 out of 10 can really stay calm and rational and give first-aid. What I'm trying to say is that.. Even if you know how to do something, doesn't mean that you automatically do that in an intense real life situation. Especially when lives are on the line. It must suck to be the 'freezer', but there's really nothing one can do afterwards and if one can't get over it with time, it'll probably be very infuriating to read about so I get you. It seems like the potential is there in this particular novel and the relationships seem to be meant to be the heart of the book so it's too bad that you didn't really care for them. Better luck next time, perhaps?
ReplyDeleteSorry this one wasn't an amazing read for you like it has been for so many other people. I have also heard from someone else that they found Imogen's character to be a little grating though, so I'm a little unsure what to think... ultimately, I think you're right when you say it is entirely personal so I would have to read it for myself to find out how I feel about her. I've never read a contemporary book that dealt with PTSD, so that's the main draw for me to read this (along with all the positive reviews). Nicely reviewed, Jenni - your thoughts always make for a nice read!
ReplyDeleteThis sounds good, but it's too bad it didn't quite work for you. Imogen sounds like a character that might start to bother me after a while. It sounds like an interesting story though, but I don't think I would rush out to pick it up.
ReplyDeleteI recently bought this one, so hopefully Imogen's emotional turmoil won't end up grating on me like it did you. Though I completely understand how you feel—I get that way with a lot of books, where you just want progress to be made.
ReplyDeleteOmg, Jenni. You and I are one of the very, very few people who don't absolutely nuts about this book--I gave it three stars as well, I also liked but didn't love it.
ReplyDeleteI had the same feeling of disconnect and missed opportunities as you did. (And I know from previous conversations with you about mass shootings and such that you are exactly the type of reader who would normally love a book like this.) Two months after reading it, I'm still surprised whenever I see a rave review pop up for it--it seemed to me to be a perfectly serviceable book, but not much more than that. I wish I'd felt something for Imogen other than dispassionate interest.
Oh, well. I'm glad other people have liked it better. But selfishly, I'm glad I'm not alone in feeling this way about the book, hah. I was starting to question whether I was all cranky-pants when I read it. ;)
This left a stronger impression on me, but I wasn't too happy with the best friend/brother issue and how it was resolved. On the other hand, just like you, I found it easier to connect to her relationship with her father. His self-destructive behavior really affected me.
ReplyDeleteI really thought this was simply, yet gorgeously written and I liked how Skilton explored powerlessness and fear.
I'm sorry you didn't like this just a bit more, but I'm glad you didn't hate it, hah.
Lovely review, Jenni!
I'm with you. I always like to see how characters deal with trauma and the far-reaching effects it has on their lives. The premise of this one is certainly unique. Two thumbs up for originality.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like it has some potential. Imogen seems to go through a lot, and this does sounds like it has its emotional moments. Sucks you really didn't connect with her as you wanted to but was still able to enjoy some of it. Great review.
ReplyDeleteJenea @ Books Live Forever
Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts with us! I'll have to read the book to see if I'd be able to tune into the inner turmoil that Imogen goes through but I'm glad that overall you still find the book entertaining.
ReplyDeleteOooo PTSD, that's unusual - I honestly had NO idea what this book was about until now, although I've seen it around. Connecting with characters can be such a personal thing, and when it doesn't happen it's disappointing.
ReplyDeleteGreat review, I'm still going to check this one out :)
Oh, it's too bad you didn't feel a strong connection with the story. It does seem like a good story. Nice review!
ReplyDeleteThank you for this well thought-out review, Jenni. I'm still going to give this one a shot, because I'm always interested in how authors tackle PTSD, but I guess I won't set my expectations high. Rushed resolutions are a pet peeve of mine, and it looks like this book has its fair share.
ReplyDeleteLyra @ Defiantly Deviant
I've seen some pretty rave reviews about this book so it's lovely to see some so-so opinions! I can totally see how her constant turmoil and inner-dialogue would become a bit old, especially if nothing is actually progressing. I think I'll continue my plan to skip this one but great review, Jenni!
ReplyDeleteBonnie @ Sweet Tidbits
I'm sorry this one didn't work as well for you, but I'm glad to hear you related to Imogen and her father's relationship, and that it was enjoyable enough for three stars. I also found her relationship with her dad to be one of the strongest in the book. I totally understand Imogen not endearing herself to you, she certainly isn't the most likable character throughout much of her PTSD recovery process. Lovely thoughtful review Jenni, thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like Bruised didn't live up to its potential by missing great opportunities such as a sweet and well-built romance. I also easily get bored when certain emotions like inner "turmoil" take precedence over everything else. It's easy to want to skip over those pages.
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to really enjoy a story when you don't fully connect with the characters. I don't like it when a character is constantly down on their actions or lack thereof. It becomes frustrating after a while. Great review, Jenni. I can see how this could be disappointing.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds exactly like how I felt with the MC of Dare You To and EVERYONE ELSE loved it, but her inability to EVER give herself a little slack just grated on me you know. The whole broken character bit might have been overplayed lately and we have less patience for the type. Dunno.
ReplyDeleteMissing connections between characters would be disappointing. I would want to know what happened in the fight between Imogen and her bff as well. The concept is interesting and I think I would really feel for her. I'm going to put this one the 'maybe' shelf. Great review!
ReplyDeleteHuh, I like books that have to do with PTSD, but I need to really, truly connect with the character. I'm not sure I would be able to do that with this book -- probably because the whole time I would be yelling in my head that martial arts are kind of no match for a person with a freakin' gun. Alas.
ReplyDeleteAt least the parental relationship in Bruised sounds good. :-)
It was very refreshing to read your thoughts after reading so many other glowing reviews. Although I do find myself disappointed when I'm the apparent black sheep out of all my friends. But I can totally see how it could be annoying how the emotional turmoil overflowed and took precedence over every other aspect in the novel. And I'm not sure whether I'd really enjoy this book or not. It sounds interesting and unique, but those qualities by themselves do not a good book make. Hmm I'll have to think more about this book.
ReplyDelete